bob_gratton:

Yes, I am about to finish my work day, I will spend a bit of time to review todays logos. Thanks to all for your submissions and your hard work :)

bob_gratton:

After reviewing all the submissions, first of all, thanks again. As a general comment over all the logos, I would like to point out that even though I like the green colour and all its shades, the logo is absolutely not required to be entirely green, or even contain green at all. In the initial specifications it is mentioned that the company is “green and eco-friendly”. Maybe green was not the most appropriate word, but in my native language, french, we often say that an idea or a company’s practises are green to mean that they are geared towards a better environment.

bob_gratton:

It would be cool if someone could take inspiration from these two Pulpix submissions:

this one

and that one

And magically fuse them together :)

bob_gratton:

Think CMYK, RGB, stuff like that… print vs display etc

bob_gratton:

Yes Steve. About that, I would like to post in the general comments something that belongs more here. Cheketere asked:

“Bob I like to know, if you decide the winner by your own or you gonna to present to others people.. this way we all know if worth make new concepts or just make combinations of the other people ideas”

To which I answered:

it’s always better to make new concepts. even though there have been some very very nice logos, there still has to come a logo where i would like to say: “ok stop the competition this is the winner”.

and yes, i have been showing the logos to various people and have been getting comments on that too. as you can see i am trying to pass as much feedback as early as possible so that the fine artists on this website know in which direction to go.

bob_gratton:

Thanks for the advice LogoFreek :) I have modified my comment. You are perfectly right, it is too early to declare anything. I will be simply giving as much constructive feedback as possible :)

bob_gratton:

TAVO thanks for your question. You are not the first person to ask that. Unfortunately you can still not see what the final version will look like because it is still in development. You might want to look at one of our competitors. Have a look at this document here

As you can see, the final result still looks like a paper. You can flip the pages by dragging the corners, and the result looks like an actual magazine. But this illusion of paper is made with the pixels of your monitor. I hope this makes it clearer.

bob_gratton:

Yes. First of all, thank you all again for your submissions. I’m sure you all worked very hard to create and revise them. Also thanks for letting me in your community. I want to mention that I like how all the artists here support each other. It makes the competition very enjoyable.

Here are my top favourite logos. I haven’t listed their variations if there are any. I have not listed them in order of preference, simply in the reverse order that they were submitted:

logo

logo

logo

logo

logo

logo

logo

logo

I might have missed some, as I just had to go through all the list in order to answer your question. I had never thought of bookmarking my favourites.

bob_gratton:

Thanks to everyone for your submissions. I’ve rechecked them all one by one since the competition closed, and I figured out the top 5 designs. I will tell you the winner by tomorrow.

Thanks!

bob_gratton:

Yes. I’ve reduced it to 3 logos. This one by Atini, this one by mia and this one by AlexWende

The common point between these 3 logos (besides that I like them the most) is that they have an icon separate from the name, and I’ve come to realize that this might be desirable. I will be showing the logo to a few people, and I promise that Monday you will have a final answer.

Thanks everyone!

bob_gratton:

Congratulations Alex. Everyone I’ve shown this competition to in my surroundings agrees with me that you should be the winner :) Thanks again to everyone for your hard work.